RE: deSkolemizing to get Horn-expressivity with RDF rules

From: mburke ([email protected])
Date: 11/22/02

  • Next message: Benjamin Grosof: "RE: deSkolemizing to get Horn-expressivity with RDF rules"
    Please make sure that there  are adequate use cases, related to DAML-S
    I believe DAML-Services has a critical need for the rule language.
    
    Thanks.
    
    Murray
    
    Murray A. Burke
    Program Manager
    DARPA/IXO
    3701 N. Fairfax Drive		Phone: 703-696-2303
    Arlington, VA 22203-1714	Fax:   517-218-4550
    mailto: [email protected]	DSN:        426-2303
    
    -----Original Message-----
    From: Harold Boley [mailto:[email protected]] 
    Sent: Wednesday, November 20, 2002 10:16 PM
    To: Sandro Hawke
    Cc: [email protected]
    Subject: Re: deSkolemizing to get Horn-expressivity with RDF rules
    
    Hi Sandro,
    
    > > As I hinted at in a different thread, it should be helpful to exchange
    > > our experience with rule engines such as cwm/n3 and Mandarax/RuleML or
    > > j-DREW/RuleML.
    > 
    > What would you suggest?   Our cwm/n3 work is all in a public cvs
    > repository, but it hasn't been properly written up.  We're still
    > trying to understand what aspects of it are novel and/or useful.   Do
    > you have ideas for a process that might work here?
    
    We could jointly announce, on rdf-rules, to start an exchange of experience
    about rule engines and tools between N3, RuleML, and related rule languages:
    
    . . .
    
    For this purpose we are collecting use cases beginning with three initial
    examples. Further use-case proposals should be sent to rdf-rules.
    
    One example of these, GEDCOM, already happens to be in the N3 collection,
    http://www.w3.org/2000/10/swap/Examples, as well as in the RuleML
    collection,
    http://www.ruleml.org/#Library. Further ones could also find their way into
    these individual collections or, a common collection could be established.
    
    1. GEDCOM (Author: Mike Dean)
    This has already been used to demonstrate aspects of N3 and RuleML.
    
    2. Authentication (Author: Tim Berners-Lee)
    Versions of an authentication rule have been written in both N3 and RuleML;
    these could be jointly extended.
    
    3. Open ...
    
    Our rule engines will be tried on these examples to compare and possibly
    later align:
    
    * Expressiveness
     - Triples
     - Horn rules
     - Negation
     - Contexts/Modules
     - Other
    
    * Built-ins
     - Arithmetics
     - Sequences
     - Other
    
    * Basic bottom-up and top-down derivation, as well as combined techniques
      (e.g., cashing/tabeling)
     - Memory use
     - Response time
    
    * Rule interpretation
    
    * Rule compilation
     - SQL
     - Rete
     - WAM
    
    * Rule transformation
     - XSLT-based
     - Other
    
    * Rule development tools
     - Editors
     - Validators
     - Cross-referencers
    
    * Web-tool embedding
     - Client-side embedding
     - Server-side embedding
    
    * Conventional-software integration
     - Rule-engine API and programming-language interfaces
     - Database and data bindings
    


    This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.4 : 11/22/02 EST